Cash-and-carry arbitrage is a market-neutral strategy that involves taking a long position in an asset (usually a commodity or financial instrument) and simultaneously taking a short position in a futures contract on that same asset. The goal is to exploit the price difference between the spot price (current market price) and the futures price to generate a risk-free profit at expiry. This strategy is commonly applied to commodities like gold, oil, and stock indices but can also be used with interest rate products and currencies.
How Cash-and-Carry Arbitrage Works
- Identify Discrepancy: The arbitrageur spots a price gap between the spot and futures markets.
- Buy Spot, Sell Futures: Purchase the asset in the spot market while selling a futures contract for the same asset.
- Cover Carry Costs: Account for expenses like storage, insurance, and financing during the holding period.
- Deliver at Expiry: Settle the futures contract by delivering the asset, closing both positions.
Profit Formula:
[ \text{Arbitrage Profit} = \text{Futures Price} - (\text{Spot Price} + \text{Carry Costs}) ]
Example: Gold Arbitrage
- Spot Price: $1,800/oz
- 3-Month Futures Price: $1,850/oz
- Carry Costs: $100
- Profit: $1,850 - ($1,800 + $100) = **$50/oz**
👉 Discover how top traders leverage arbitrage strategies
Key Components
Spot vs. Futures Prices
- Spot Price: Immediate transaction price.
- Futures Price: Agreed-upon future delivery price, typically higher due to carry costs and time value.
Carry Costs
- Storage fees
- Insurance
- Financing (interest on borrowed funds)
- Miscellaneous holding expenses
Market Conditions
Contango (Futures > Spot)
Ideal for cash-and-carry arbitrage. Common when:
- Asset prices are expected to rise.
- High storage/demand costs exist.
Backwardation (Futures < Spot)
Reverse cash-and-carry strategies may apply. Caused by:
- Short-term supply shortages.
- Immediate demand spikes.
Risks to Consider
| Risk Type | Description |
|---|---|
| Market Risk | Spot price fluctuations before futures expiry. |
| Basis Risk | Unpredictable changes in the spot-futures price gap. |
| Liquidity Risk | Difficulty entering/exiting positions without affecting prices. |
| Counterparty Risk | Default risk in futures contracts (mitigated by regulated exchanges). |
👉 Explore risk management tools for arbitrage trading
Algorithmic Approaches
Modern trading firms use algorithms to:
- Scan Markets: Detect price discrepancies across exchanges.
- Execute Trades: Optimize trade timing and minimize market impact.
- Manage Risk: Monitor costs and adjust positions dynamically.
Notable Firms:
- Citadel LLC
- DE Shaw & Co.
- Jane Street Group
FAQs
Q: Is cash-and-carry arbitrage truly risk-free?
A: While theoretically risk-free, practical risks like basis risk or liquidity issues can affect outcomes.
Q: Which assets are best for this strategy?
A: Commodities (gold, oil) and liquid financial instruments with active futures markets.
Q: How do carry costs impact profitability?
A: Higher carry costs reduce arbitrage profits—precise calculation is critical.
Q: Can retail traders execute cash-and-carry arbitrage?
A: Yes, but requires access to spot/futures markets and capital to cover carry costs.
Conclusion
Cash-and-carry arbitrage remains a cornerstone of market-neutral trading, offering risk-free profits when spot-futures price gaps exceed carry costs. Advances in algorithmic trading have amplified its efficiency, making it a staple for institutional and quantitative traders. By mastering the interplay of spot prices, futures premiums, and cost management, traders can harness this strategy across diverse asset classes.